9 Comments
User's avatar
Lisa Schonhoff's avatar

This is false information. You absolutely must be instructing students at their level AND provide them with grade level text AND provide them with text below their level all for different reasons. We need to stop with the all or nothing mentality. It’s killing our proficiency!

Karen Vaites's avatar

I'd suggest actually reading the post.

Lisa Schonhoff's avatar

Actually, my next question is how many years have you been teaching kids to read? It sounds like you listened to the Sold a Story podcast, read a couple books, and decided that you were an expert because the things you’re saying are not making sense.

Lisa Schonhoff's avatar

I did and you are severely misleading your audience. Another aspect that is severely misleading is your promotion of CKLA and other curriculums that keep kids out of physical books and on screens. Please rethink your extremist stance. Phonics and explicit instruction has been missing but let’s not throw away the baby with the bath water. Let’s keep the pendulum where it belongs, somewhere in the middle with a healthy dose of common sense.

Karen Vaites's avatar

Core Knowledge is a curriculum designed in the 1980’s (and since refined by Amplify). Nothing about the original versions requires use of screens, and the Amplify versions have added more whole books. I would actually say the phonics aspect of CKLA is not the strongest part of the materials, but I digress… it’s worth looking into the materials in detail, you might be surprised by what you learn.

Lisa Schonhoff's avatar

Have you actually taught any of these curriculum materials or been in schools observing them? Can you please share where you expertise comes from or who is paying you?

https://www.lisafornebraska.com/post/what-is-ckla-and-where-did-it-come-from

Lisa Schonhoff's avatar

I’ve written a couple blog posts on it. I have delved into it a great deal.

https://www.lisafornebraska.com/post/what-s-in-your-child-s-classroom

English Champion's avatar

Good analysis here...

When I started my teaching career with 5th graders back in 2001, this is what my school did. It was all-in on "balanced literacy" and the trendy methodology of leveled reading groups of the time. Sad that it still exists in some schools today. I could tell immediately, even as a 22-year-old, that it didn't work. It's one of the many reasons I left to go teach college students instead. Unfortunately, the bad reading instruction initiated in elementary schools continues to harm them at the college level as well. We need to start over.

English as a 2nd Language: IB's avatar

Thanks for this article. Really insightful. I teach HS English as a second language and I do exactly what it tells me not to: I use AI to take a challenging text and lexical differentiate. I have built an AI that keeps the content, just reduces lexical density. Without doing so, I found some kids were stopping at far too many unknown words. What does the research say about this? Very respectfully